Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Exercise 2: Operational ECMWF HRES forecast

...

HRES performance

Exercise 1 looked at the synoptic development up to the 20-Sept-2012. This exercise looks at the ECMWF HRES forecast from this date and how the IFS model developed the interaction between Hurricane Nadine and the cut-off low.

...

Before looking at the ensemble forecasts, first understand the performance behaviour of the operational HRES forecast of the time.

...

Data is provided for a single 5 10 day forecast starting from 20th Sept 2012, as used in the paper by Pantillon et al. referred to at the start of this tutorial.

...

.

Data is provided at the same resolution as the operational model, in order to give the best representation of the Hurricane and cut-off low iterations. This may mean that some plotting will be slow.

...

The parameters available in the analyses are also available in the forecast data.

Available plot types

Warning

TODO: check macros have not changed

Panel

For this exercise, you will use the metview icons in the folder 'HRES_forecast' shown above.

hres_1x1.mv & hres_2x2.mv    : these work in a similar way to the same icons used in the previous task where parameters from a single lead time can be plotted either in a single frame or 4 frame per page.
hres_xs.mv
                                 : this plots a vertical cross section and can be used to compare the vertical structure of Hurricane Nadine and the cut-off low.

TODO: check macros have not changed

Task 1: Synoptic development (day 0-5)

Warning

TODO: include data to day 8 (if possible). Then have task1 to look at day 0-4, and include another task which looks at tracking the systems to day 8 in the forecast & overlay the manual_track.csv file with the mv_track.mv icon.

Not sure how best to organise tasks as the animations will show all days?

From 20th to 25th September, Nadine had lost hurricane intensity and was slowly moving over the North Atlantic. A short-wave trough separated into a cutoff and approached from the north. Nadine interacted with a cold front associated with the cutoff on 21st September.

MSLP and geopotential height

Study the forecast scenario to day+5, focus on:

  1. the evolution of Nadine,
  2. the fate of the cutoff low,
  3. the precipitation over France.

You can use the hres_1x1.mv and hres_2x2.mv icons in the same way as Exercise 1 when looking at the analyses.

Although the macros will animate the data for the whole forecast, for this task concentrate on the forecast for the first 5 days.

For example, to plot geopotential at 500hPa and MSLP using the hres_1x1.mv macro, right click, select Edit and putFirst plot the geopotential at 500hPa and MSLP using the hres_1x1.mv macro script to see the large scale circulation and track the development of the systems:

Code Block
plot1=["z500.s","mslp"]

Drag To add the forecast track of Hurricane Nadine drag and drop the mv_track.mv icon onto the map to add the forecast track of Hurricane Nadineany map.

Warning

TODO: add the manually created track file for the forecast track and copy mv_track.mv icon into the HRES folder.

Temperature and mid-troposphere patterns

Next use the hres_2x2.mv macro to plot additional fields looking at different aspects of the forecasts. Right click and select 'Edit' and change the plot list to:

Code Block
plot1=["t2","mslp"]
plot2=["mslp","wind10"]
plot3=["t500","z500"]
plot4=["t850","z850"]

...


Panel
borderColorred
borderStylesolid
titleQuestions to consider

Q. How strongly does Nadine appear to interact with the cutoff?
Q. What is the fate of the cutoff low and what synoptic conditions did it create over France?

Precipitation over France

Choose a hres macro and plot the total precipitation (parameter: tp), near surface wind field (parameter: wind10), relative humidity (parameter: r).

Other suggested isobaric maps

Using either the hres_1x1.mv or hres_2x2.mv macro plot some of these other maps to study the synoptic development.

Panel
borderColorgrey
borderWidth1
borderStyledashed
  • "vo850", "mslp"        : vorticity at 850hPa and MSLP  -  low level signature of Nadine and disturbance associated with the cutoff low.
  • "r700", "mslp",         : MSLP + relative humidity at 700hPa  -  with mid-level humidity of the systems
  • "pv320K", "mslp"     : 320K potential vorticity (PV) + MSLP  -   upper level conditions, upper level jet and the cutoff signature in PV, interaction between Nadine and the cut-off low.
  • "wind850", "w700"   : Winds at 850hPa + vertical velocity at 700hPa (+MSLP) : focus on moist and warm air in the lower levels and associated vertical motion.
  • "t2", "mslp"              : 2m-temperature and MSLP - low level signature of Nadine and temperature.
  • "mslp", "wind10"      : MSLP + 10m winds  -   interesting for Nadine's tracking and primary circulation.
  • "t500","z500"          : Geopotential + temperature at 500hPa  -  large scale patterns, mid-troposphere position of warm Nadine and the cold Atlantic cutoff.
  • "t850", "z850"         : Geopotential + temperature at 850hPa  -  lower level conditions, detection of fronts


Task 2: Vertical structure and forecast evolution to day 10

This task examines vertical PV cross-sections of Nadine and the cutoff at different forecast times to characterize the diabatic warm core PV tower of Nadine compared to the upper level PV cold core of the cutoff.

Right-click on the icon 'hres

...

Using either the hres_1x1.mv or hres_2x2.mv macro plot some of these other maps to study the synoptic development. Note for example that there should not be a strong horizontal temperature gradient around Nadine (why?) and the winds should be stronger for Nadine than the cutoff.

Panel
titleOther suggested isobaric maps
  • "vo850", "mslp"           : vorticity at 850hPa and MSLP  -  low level signature of Nadine and disturbance associated with the cutoff low.
  • "r700", "mslp",            : MSLP + relative humidity at 700hPa  -  with mid-level humidity of the systems
  • "pv320K", "mslp"        : 320K potential vorticity (PV) + MSLP  -   upper level conditions, upper level jet and the cutoff signature in PV, interaction between Nadine and the cut-off low.
  • "wind850", "w700"      : Winds at 850hPa + vertical velocity at 700hPa (+MSLP) : focus on moist and warm air in the lower levels and associated vertical motion.
Warning

TODO:

If we get data for day 5-8, include another task here to look at vertical structure and track storm.

Overlay the manual_track.csv file on top of the mslp & z500 map.

This will lead to Fred's discussion of the CPS (cyclone phase space) diagram.

Fred/Etienne - Any other tasks / questions? I'm not sure what questions you want to ask.

Vertical structure

Warning

TODO: this becomes part of new task 2 if we get days 5-8 data.

This part of the task is to look at cross-sections through Hurricane Nadine and the cut-off low.

Right-click on the icon 'hres_xs.mv' icon, select 'Edit' and push the play button.

...

This means the 'steps' value in the macros is only valid for the times:  [2012-09-20 00:00], [2012-09-21 00:00], [2012-09-22 00:00], [2012-09-23 00:00], [2012-09-24 00:00], [2012-09-25 00:00]

Warning

TODO: change this if we get more x-section data to day 8.

etc.

To change To change the date/time of the plot, edit the macro and change the line:

Code Block
steps=[2012-09-22 00:00]
Changing

...

cross-section location
Code Block
#Cross section line [ South, West, North, East ]
line = [30,-29,45,-15]

The cross-section location (red line) can be changed in this macro by defining the end points of the line as shown above.

If the forecast time is changed, the storm centres will move and the cross-section line will need to be repositioned to follow specific features. This is not computed automatically, but must be changed by altering the coordinates above.

Panel
borderColorred
borderStylesolid

Q. Does this kind of Hurricane landfall event over the Iberian peninsula happen often?

Suggestions for other vertical cross-sections

A reduced number of fields is available for cross-sections compared to the isobaric maps: temperature (t), potential temperature (pt), relative humidity (r), potential vorticity (pv), vertical velocity (w), wind-speed (speed; sqrt(u*u+v*v)) and wind vectors (wind3).

Choose from the following (note the cross-section macro hres_xs.mv uses slightly different names for the parameters).

Panel
  • "pt", "pv"              : Potential temperature + potential vorticity to characterize the cold core and warm core structures of Hurricane Nadine and the cut-off low.
  • "r", "w"                 : Humidity + vertical motion :   another view of the cold core and warm core structures of Hurricane Nadine and the cut-off low.
  • "pv", "w" ("r")       : Potential vorticity + vertical velocity (+ relative humidity) :  a classical cross-section to see if a PV anomaly is accompanied with vertical motion or not.

A reduced number of fields is available for cross-sections compared to the isobaric maps: temperature (t), potential temperature (pt), relative humidity (r), potential vorticity (pv), vertical velocity (w), wind-speed (speed; sqrt(u*u+v*v)) and wind vectors (wind3).

Choose from the following (note the cross-section macro hres_xs.mv uses slightly different names for the parameters).

Panel
titleSuggestions for other vertical cross-sections
  • "pt", "pv"              : Potential temperature + potential vorticity to characterize the cold core and warm core structures of Hurricane Nadine and the cut-off low.
  • "r", "w"                 : Humidity + vertical motion :   another view of the cold core and warm core structures of Hurricane Nadine and the cut-off low.
  • "pv", "w" ("r")       : Potential vorticity + vertical velocity (+ relative humidity) :  a classical cross-section to see if a PV anomaly is accompanied with vertical motion or not.
Changing cross-section location
Code Block
#Cross section line [ South, West, North, East ]
line = [30,-29,45,-15]

The cross-section location (red line) can be changed in this macro by defining the end points of the line as shown above.

Remember that if the forecast time is changed, the storm centres will move and the cross-section line will need to be repositioned to follow specific features. This is not computed automatically, but must be changed by altering the coordinates above.

For help on how to save images, see the beginning of this tutorial.

Panel
borderColorred
borderStylesolid
titleQuestions to consider

Q. How strongly does Nadine appear to interact with the cutoff?
Q. What is the fate of the cutoff low and what synoptic conditions did it create over France?

Task 2: Precipitation over France

Warning

TODO: if we get data to day 8, this becomes task 3.

Choose a hres macro to use, plot the total precipitation (parameter: tp), near surface wind field (parameter: wind10), relative humidity (parameter: r) (and any other parameters of interest).

The macros hres_1x1.mv, hres_2x2.mv and hres_xs.mv can be used to plot and animate fields or overlays of fields from the HRES forecast.

Panel
borderColorred
Q. What do you think about the quality of this forecast? And why?

Exercise 3 : Operational ensemble forecasts

...

Make sure clustersId="off" for this task. Clustering will be used later.

Precipitation over France

Use stamp.mv and plot total precipitation ('tp') over France (mapType=2) for 00Z 24-09-2012.

...