You are viewing an old version of this page. View the current version.

Compare with Current View Page History

« Previous Version 2 Next »

Comparison of scores of IFS cycle 41r2 (combination of research experiments and the current e-suite) and IFS cycle 41r1 (the current operational cycle) verified by the respective analyses or radiosonde observations at 00UTC for the period 00 UTC on 1 January 2015 to 12 UTC on 30 November 2015.

High resolution

    ACCRMSe/STDeSEEPS
Europeagainst
analysis
Geopotential100hPa▲▲▴▴▴░░░░░▼▼▼▼▾▾░▾▾░ 
500hPa▲▴▴▴▴░░░░░▲▲▴▴▴▴░░░░ 
MSL pressure ▲▴▴▴▴░░░░░▴▴▴▴▴▴░░░░ 
Temperature100hPa▲▲▲▲▴▴░░░░▲▲▲▴▴░░░░░ 
200hPa▲▲▴▴▴░░░░░▲▲▴▴▴░░░░░ 
850hPa▲▲▲▴▴▴░░░░▲▲▲▴▴▴░░░░ 
Wind100hPa▲▲▲▲▲▴▴░░░▲▲▲▲▲▴▴░░░ 
200hPa▲▲▴▴▴▴░░░░▲▲▴▴▴▴░░░░ 
850hPa▲▲▴▴▴▴░░░░▲▲▴▴▴▴░░░░ 
Relative
humidity
300hPa▲▲▴▴▴▴░▴░░▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴▴ 
700hPa▲▲▲▴▴▴░░░░▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴░ 
against
observations
Temperature100hPa░░▾░░░░░░░▾▾▼▼▾░░░▾▾ 
200hPa░░░▴▴░░░░░░░░▴░░░░░░ 
850hPa░▴░▴▴░░░░░░▴▴▴▴▴░░░░ 
2m temperature  ▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴ 
Wind100hPa▾▾▾▾░░░░░░░▾▾░░░░░░░ 
200hPa░░░▴▴░░░░░░░░▴▴▴░░░░ 
850hPa░░░▴▴▴░░░░░░░▴▴▴░░░░ 
10m wind  ▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴ 
2m dew-point ▲▲▲▴▴▴▴░░░ 
Total cloud cover ░░░░░░░░░░ 
24h precipitation  ░░▴▴▴░░░░░
Extratropical
Northern
Hemisphere
against
analysis
Geopotential100hPa▴▴▴▴▴▴░░░░▾▼▼▼▾▾▾░░▾ 
500hPa▲▲▲▴▴▴░░░░▲▲▲▴▴▴▴░░░ 
MSL pressure ▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴▴░▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴░░ 
Temperature100hPa▴▴▴▴▴▲▴▲▴▴▲▲▴▲▴▴▴░░░ 
200hPa▲▲▲▲▴▴▴░░░▲▲▴▴▴░░░░░ 
850hPa▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴░░▲▲▲▲▴▴▴░▴░ 
Wind100hPa▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴░ 
200hPa▲▲▲▴▴▴▴▴▴░▲▲▲▴▴▴▴▴░░ 
850hPa▾▴▲▴▴▴▴▴▴░▾▴▲▴▴▴▴░░░ 
10m wind
over ocean
 ▼░░▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▼▾░░░░░░░░ 
Ocean wave
height
░░░░▴░▴▴▴▴▾░░░░░░░░░ 
Ocean wave
period
▼▾▾▾░░░░░░▼▼▼▼▾▾▾▾▾▾ 
Relative
humidity
300hPa▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▴ 
700hPa▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴░▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴ 
against
observations
Temperature100hPa▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴░░░░░░░░░░▾ 
200hPa▴▴▴▴▴▴▴░░░░░▴▴▴░░░░░ 
850hPa▴▲▲▴▴▴░▴░░▴▲▲▴▴▴░▴░░ 
2m temperature  ▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴░ 
Wind100hPa▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴░▲▴▴▴▴▴▴▴░░ 
200hPa▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴░░▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴░░ 
850hPa▾░░▴▴▴▴░░░▾░░░▴░░░░░ 
10m wind  ▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▲ 
2m dew-point ▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴░ 
Total cloud cover ░░░▴░░░░░░ 
24h precipitation  ░░░▴▴▴▴▴░░
Extratropical
Southern
Hemisphere
against
analysis
Geopotential100hPa▲▲▲▴▴▴▴░░░▼▼▾░░░░░░░ 
500hPa▲▲▲▲▴▴░░░░▲▲▲▲▴▴▴░░░ 
MSL pressure ▲▲▲▲▴▴▴░░░▲▲▲▲▴▴▴░░░ 
Temperature100hPa▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴░░▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴░░ 
200hPa▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴░▴▲▲▲▴▴▴▴░░░ 
850hPa▲▲▲▲▲▴▴░░░▲▲▲▲▲▴▴░░░ 
Wind100hPa▲▲▲▲▲▴▴░░░▲▲▲▲▲▴▴░░░ 
200hPa▲▲▲▲▴▴▴░░░▲▲▲▲▴▴▴░░░ 
850hPa▾▲▲▲▴▴▴░░▴▾▲▲▲▲▴▴░░░ 
10m wind
over ocean
 ▼░▴▲▴▴▴░░░▼░▴▲▴▴▴░░░ 
Ocean wave
height
▴▲▴▴▴▴▴░░░░▴▴▴▴▴░░░░ 
Ocean wave
period
▼▾░▴▴▴▴░░░▼▼▼▾░░░▾▾▾ 
Relative
humidity
300hPa▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴░░▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴ 
700hPa▴▲▲▲▲▴▴░░▴▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴ 
against
observations
Temperature100hPa▾░░░░░░░░░▾▾▾░░░░░░░ 
200hPa░░▴▴░░▴░▴▴░░░░░░░░░░ 
850hPa░▴▴▴▴░▴░░░░▴▴▴▴▴▴░░░ 
2m temperature  ▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴▴ 
Wind100hPa░░░▴░▴▴▴░░░░░▴░▴░░░░ 
200hPa░▴▴▴░▴▴░▴░▴▴▴▴▴▴▴░░▴ 
850hPa░░▴░░▴▴░░▴░▴▴░░▴▴░░▴ 
10m wind  ▴▲▴▴▴▴▴░░░ 
2m dew-point ▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▴ 
Total cloud cover ░░░░░░░░░░ 
24h precipitation  ░░░▴░░░░░░
Tropicsagainst
analysis
Temperature100hPa░░▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴░░▴▴▴▴▴▴░░ 
200hPa▲▴▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▾▾░▴▴▴▲▴▴▴ 
850hPa▼▴▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▾▴▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴ 
Wind100hPa▼░░░▴▴▴▴▴░▾░░▴▴▴▴▴▴▴ 
200hPa▼▾░▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▼░░▴▴▴▴▴▴▴ 
850hPa▼▼░▴▴▴▲▴▴▴▼▼▾░░▴▴▴▴░ 
10m wind
over ocean
 ▼▼░▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▼▼▼▾░░░░░░ 
Ocean wave
height
▾▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▼▾░░░▾░░░░ 
Ocean wave
period
▼▴▴▴▲▲▴▴▴▴▼▼▼▼▼▾▾▾▾▾ 
Relative
humidity
300hPa▴▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴▴▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▴▴ 
700hPa▼▼░▴▴▲▲▲▴░▼▾▴▲▲▲▲▲▲▴ 
against
observations
Temperature100hPa░░░░▴░▴▴░░▾░░░░░░░▾▾ 
200hPa░░░░░░░░░░▾▾▾▾▾▾▾▾░░ 
850hPa░░░▴▴▴░▴░░░░░▴▴▴░▴░░ 
2m temperature  ▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▲ 
Wind100hPa░▴▴▴░░░░░░░░▴░░░░░░░ 
200hPa▴▴▴▴▴▴░▴░▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴▴ 
850hPa░▴░░▴░░░░░░▴░░▴░░░░░ 
10m wind  ▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▲▲ 
2m dew-point ▴▴▴▲▴▴▴░░░ 
Total cloud cover ░▴▴▴▴▴▴░▴░ 
24h precipitation  ▼▼▼▼▾▾▾▾▾▾

 

Extended HRES scorecard

Comparison for additional domains can be found in the extended HRES scorecards

 

Score card provides a quick visual overview over the performance of the CY41r2 scores compared to CY41r1. It is a simplified summary of verify error plots of various domains, scores, parameters etc.
Each error plot is converted into a sequence of symbols (e.g. ▼ ▾ ▾ ░ ░ ░ ░ ▴ ▲ ▲) where each symbol indicates for given time step whether or not the CY41r2 is significantly better or worse than the CY41r1.
Symbol legend: for a given forecast step... (d: score difference, s: confidence interval width)
▲ CY41r2 better than CY41r1 statistically highly significant (the confidence bar above zero by more than its height )(d/s>3)
▴ CY41r2 better than CY41r1 statistically significant (d/s≥1)
░ CY41r2 better than CY41r1, yet not statistically significant (d/s≥0.5)
░ not really any difference between CY41r1 and CY41r2
░ CY41r2 worse than CY41r1, yet not statistically significant (d/s≤-0.5)
▾ CY41r2 worse than CY41r1 statistically significant (d/s≤-1)
▼ CY41r2 worse than CY41r1 statistically highly significant (the confidence bar below zero by more than its height) (d/s<-3)

 

  • No labels